Back to Blog
April 16, 2024

How to Give a Great Employee Performance Review (Tips for Managers)

How to Give a Great Employee Performance Review (Tips for Managers)

📝 Performance Review Tips for Managers

Performance reviews are an essential part of managing a team. They provide an opportunity for managers to sit down with their team members and set expectations for the following year. In this article, we will discuss five tips to help you conduct a meaningful and flawless performance review with your team.

Tip 1: Collect Your Thoughts

Before you review your team member's self-evaluation, it's important to look at your own perspective of how your team is doing. Ask yourself questions like, "Have I given ongoing feedback throughout the year?" and "Have they been responsive to that feedback?" You also want to look at what their career goals and aspirations are and make sure they align with where you would like them to go in the next year.

Tip 2: Review Their Self-Evaluation

Most organizations have a formal self-evaluation process, but if yours doesn't, ask your team members to do a self-evaluation. Look for patterns in their strengths and weaknesses, and make sure they understand the business goals and vision.

Tip 3: Have a Face-to-Face Conversation

It's time to sit down and have a face-to-face conversation with your team member. Set a clear intention of what's going to happen in the next year and inspire them to think bigger and follow the company vision. Address any barriers to performance and set a course for growth.

Tip 4: Clarify Expectations

Make sure you are clear on what your expectations are for your team members in general and more specifically per employee. Address any changes that have happened in the past year and set guidelines for the following year.

Tip 5: Make a Hard Plan Moving Forward

Create measurable objectives, set hard dates for cross-training, and develop action plans for any projects or initiatives. Make sure the plan is actionable and that you and your team member are excited for the future.

Performance reviews are an excellent opportunity to set a course for growth and inspire your team members to think bigger. By following these tips, you can conduct a meaningful and flawless performance review with your team.

Pros

- Provides an opportunity to set expectations for the following year

- Inspires team members to think bigger and follow the company vision

- Addresses any barriers to performance and sets a course for growth

Cons

- Can be time-consuming

- Can be difficult to address performance issues

Highlights

- Collect your thoughts before reviewing your team member's self-evaluation

- Review their self-evaluation for patterns in strengths and weaknesses

- Have a face-to-face conversation to set a clear intention for the next year

- Clarify expectations for your team members

- Make a hard plan moving forward that is actionable

FAQ

Q: What should I do if my team member's self-evaluation is not aligned with the company vision?

A: Address the misalignment and work with your team member to create a plan that aligns with the company vision.

Q: How often should I conduct performance reviews?

A: Performance reviews should be conducted at least once a year.

Q: What should I do if my team member consistently fails to meet expectations?

A: Address the issue and work with your team member to create a plan for improvement. If the issue persists, consider disciplinary action.

Resources:

- [The Psychology of Successful Leaders](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JzYJvzZuJZ0)

- [Managing Remote Teams](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JzYJvzZuJZ0)

- [A Leader Without Being Bossy](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JzYJvzZuJZ0)

- [Harness Your Butterflies](https://www.amazon.com/Harness-Your-Butterflies-Ben-Preston/dp/1734761205/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=harness+your+butterflies&qid=1632939267&sr=8-1)

Related Articles

E-commerce
Amazon’s Competitors and Business Innovations: An In-Depth Analysis in 2025

Amidst a rapidly shifting digital retail landscape, the contest for dominance extends far beyond the reach of Amazon. Major competitors such as eBay, Walmart, and Alibaba are leveraging unique business models, expansive product portfolios, and innovative customer engagement strategies to claim their

Dec 29, 2025
Read more
E-commerce
Amazon Pallets for Sale: Deep Dive Guide to Profitable Sourcing and Reselling in 2024

Amazon pallets for sale represent a growing frontier for entrepreneurs and small businesses aiming to acquire goods at deep discounts. By harnessing the vast flow of returns, liquidations, and overstocked inventory, savvy buyers can procure merchandise at a fraction of retail value. The evolution of

Dec 29, 2025
Read more
E-commerce
Beyond Facebook Marketplace: Comprehensive Guide to Top Alternatives, Optimizing Sales, and Navigating the Online Selling Landscape

The landscape of online buying and selling has evolved at a meteoric pace, reshaping consumer expectations and creating vibrant digital marketplaces tailored to nearly every need. Facebook Marketplace, launched by Meta, stands as a testament to the power of peer-to-peer commerce. Its ease of use and

Dec 29, 2025
Read more
VOC AI Inc. 160 E Tasman Drive Suite 202 San Jose, CA, 95134 Copyright © 2025 VOC AI Inc.All Rights Reserved. Terms & Conditions • Privacy Policy
This website uses cookies
VOC AI uses cookies to ensure the website works properly, to store some information about your preferences, devices, and past actions. This data is aggregated or statistical, which means that we will not be able to identify you individually. You can find more details about the cookies we use and how to withdraw consent in our Privacy Policy.
We use Google Analytics to improve user experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you consent to the use of cookies and data collection by Google Analytics.
Are you happy to accept these cookies?
Accept all cookies
Reject all cookies